The New York Yankees’ set-up man, Tim Hill, was not solely responsible for the team’s close 4-3 loss to the Brewers on May 9, but a cleaner outing in the 10th inning might have helped New York extend the game into the 11th.

The Yankees entered the bottom of the 10th with a 3-2 lead after third baseman Ryan McMahon's two-out RBI single in the top.

After the game, Hill acknowledged the mistake, saying, "I made a good pitch and then a bad decision afterwards. Feel like my instinct told me third, and my instincts were wrong,” as reported by The New York Post’s Greg Joyce.

Relief pitcher Fernando Cruz started the inning and immediately lost control. The pitch moved automatic runner Garrett Mitchell to third base. He walked infielder Luis Rengifo. Jackson Chourio tied the game one batter later with an infield single, and Mitchell scored.

With runners on first and second and one out, Aaron Boone called on Tim Hill to escape the jam.

Hill initially executed his role. He forced Brice Turang to hit a soft comebacker toward the mound. The throw to first base would have recorded the second out.

But Hill trusted his instincts and turned toward third instead, trying to cut down the lead runner. The throw sailed wide and hit Rengifo in the hand. Two pitches later, William Contreras lifted a sacrifice fly to right field, and Milwaukee walked it off.

The loss dropped New York to 0-2 in the series against Milwaukee. It was also the Yankees’ first back-to-back losses since their five-game losing streak from April 8 through April 12.

Bullpen Struggles Overshadow Cam Schlittler’s Strong Start

The Yankees got the exact start they wanted from their starter, Cam Schlittler.

Schlittler pitched six scoreless innings even after taking a 108.5 mph line drive off his left calf in the first inning. Paul Goldschmidt gave the Yankees an early lead with a leadoff homer and later added another run with an RBI single.

McMahon also added the go-ahead run in the 10th inning in the extra innings to put New York ahead 3-2. But the Yankees' bullpen allowed three runs across the seventh, eighth, and tenth innings.

They had already started leaking runs before Hill ever entered the game. Camilo Doval could not protect a 2-1 lead in the eighth inning. Brice Turang singled, stole second base, and scored on William Contreras’ RBI single.

Since arriving from San Francisco last season, the right-hander has a 5.23 ERA on 32 hits allowed, five home runs, and 19 earned runs in just 32.2 innings in his Yankees tenure.

Read more on the New York Yankees Community

Written by

Md Saife Fida

Edited by

Rudra Dubey