Yankees name top spot for cubs catcher Carson Kelly

With Carson Kelly hitting free agency potentially next winter, one team that could make a lot of sense for the veteran catcher is the Yankees.
While there are certainly some other notable names in the free agent catcher pool, such as Hunter Goodman and Ryan Jeffers, Kelly could be the perfect mix of cost and skill level for the Yankees to pursue in early free agency.
The 11-year MLB veteran played for the Cubs this past season, but he could end up as a Yankee come next year if both sides don't agree on his future. Chicago has a mutual option for Kelly for next year worth $7.5 million, with a player option worth $1.5 million.
If Kelly does enter free agency next year, the Yankees could swoop in. New York would be looking to upgrade its catching tandem for 2027, as its catchers combined for just a .196 batting average and .600 OPS this year, the bulk of that coming from Austin Wells. Kelly, meanwhile, hit .258 with 10 home runs and a career-high 58 RBIs across 120 games in 2026.
Perhaps even more impressive was Kelly's bat versus left-handed pitching, slashing with a .871 OPS this year. That's where Kelly could potentially make the biggest difference, as Wells posted just a .436 OPS versus southpaws this year. Kelly could provide the Yankees with a nice platoon partner in Wells, allowing the team to take advantage of favorable matchups without giving up on its young catcher altogether.
In addition to his bat, Kelly is a reliable defender behind the dish, showing receiving skills and even posting some positive framing value in 2026.
Kelly isn't flashy, but he's a grinder who could help the Yankees in a number of ways, and he's not likely to break the bank, either. Chicago signed Kelly to a two-year, $11.5 million deal, and the Yankees could potentially do something similar.
Written by
Lakshya